George Rooke (george_rooke) wrote,
George Rooke
george_rooke

"Мыс Трафальгар" Реверте и реальный Трафальгар

Честно скажу - дочитав "Мыс Трафальгар" АПР я ужаснулся. Неужели об этом сражении кто-то судит по словам пристрастного происпанского романиста?

Умиляло буквально все. Взять то же самое Финнистере. Испанцы все в белом, французы - уроды, ну а англичане - вообще полные уроды. Однако Реверте совершенно забывает, что основной задачей Вильнева (как и немцев в ВМВ) было не потопить корабли противника, а НЕ ПОТЕРЯТЬ СВОИ КОРАБЛИ.
Кстати, Кальдер в 1805 году попал под суд, поскольку не атаковал вторично Вильнева и Гравину, хотя захватил 2 испанских корабля и имел веские причины  отказаться от боя(повреждения своих кораблей).

В сражении при Трафальгаре у Реверте виноват Вильнев, сделавший поворот все вдруг. Офигенно. Вот отчет адмирала Коллингвуда о бое:

Vice Admiral Cuthbert Collingwood's Dispatch

To William Marsden Esq., Admiralty, London

Euryalus, off Cape Trafalgar, Oct. 22.

Sir,

The ever to be lamented death of Vice Admiral Lord Viscount Nelson, who, in the late conflict with the enemy, fell in the hour of victory, leaves to me the duty of informing my Lord Commissioners of the Admiralty, that on the 19th inst. it was communicated to the Commander in Chief from the ships watching the motions of the enemy in Cadiz, that the combined fleet had put to sea; as they sailed with light winds westerly, his Lordship concluded their destination was the Mediterranean, and immediately made all sail for the Streights' entrance, with the British squadron, consisting of twenty-seven ships, three of them sixty-fours, where his Lordship was informed by Captain Blackwood (whose vigilance in watching, and giving notice of the enemy's movements, has been highly meritorious) that they had not yet passed the Streights.

On Monday, the 21st instant, at day light, when Cape Trafalgar bore E. by S. about seven leagues, the enemy was discovered six or seven miles to the eastward, the wind about west, and very light, the Commander in Chief immediately made the signal for the fleet to bear up in two columns, as they are formed in order of sailing; a mode of attack his Lordship had previously directed, to avoid the inconvenience and delay in forming a line of battle in the usual manner. The enemy's line consisted of thirty-three ships (of which 18 were French and 15 Spanish) commanded in chief by Admiral Villeneuve; the Spaniards under the direction of Gravina, wore, with their heads to the northward, and formed the line of battle with great closeness and correctness;-but as the mode of attack was unusual, so the structure of their line was new; it formed a crescent convexing to leeward-so that, in leading down to their centre, I had both their van and rear, abaft the beam; before the fire opened, every alternate ship was about a cable's length to windward of her second a-head, and a-stern, forming a kind of double line, and appeared, when on their beam, to leave a very littler interval between them; and this without crowding their ships. Admiral Villeneuve was in the Bucentaure in the centre, and the Prince of Asturias bore Gravina's flag in the rear; but the French and Spanish ships were mixed without any apparent regard to order of national squadron.

As the mode of our attack had been previously determined on, and communicated to the Flag Officers and Captains, few signals were necessary, and none were made, except to direct close order as the lines bore down. The Commander in Chief in the Victory led the weather column, and the Royal Sovereign, which bore my flag, the lee.

The action began at twelve o'clock, by the leading ships of the columns breaking through the enemy's line, the Commander in Chief about the tenth ship from the van, the Second in Command about the twelfth from the rear, leaving the van of the enemy unoccupied; the succeeding ships breaking through, in all parts, astern of their leaders, and engaging the enemy at the muzzles of their guns: the conflict was severe; the enemy's ships were fought with a gallantry highly honourable to their officers, but the attack on them was irresistible, and it pleased the Almighty Disposer of all Events, to grant his Majesty's arms a complete and glorious victory.

About three P.M. many of the enemy's ships having struck their colours, their line gave way: Admiral Gravina, with ten ships, joining their frigates to leeward, stood towards Cadiz. The five headmost ships in their van tacked, and standing to the southward, to windward, of the British line, were engaged, and the sternmost of them taken:-the others went off, leaving to his Majesty's squadron, nineteen ships of the line, (of which two are first-rates, the Santissima Trinidad and the Santa Anna) with three Flag Officers, viz. Admiral Villeneuve, the Commander in Chief, Don Ignatio Maria D'Aliva, Vice Admiral, and the Spanish Rear Admiral Don Baltazar Hidalgo Cisneros.

After such a victory it may appear unnecessary to enter into encomiums on the particular parts taken by the several Commanders; the conclusion says more on the subject than I have language to express; the spirit which animated all was the same; when all exerted themselves zealously in their country's service, all deserve that their high merits should stand recorded; and never was high merit more conspicuous than in the battle I have described.

The Achille (a French 74), after having surrendered, by some mismanagement of the Frenchmen took fire and blew up; two hundred of her men were saved by the tenders.

A circumstance occurred during the action, which so strongly marks the invincible spirit of British seamen, when engaging the enemies of their country, that I cannot resist the pleasure I have in making it known to their Lordships; the Temeraire was boarded by accident, or design, by a French ship on one side, and a Spaniard on the other; the contest was vigorous, but, in the end, the combined ensigns were torn from the poop, and the British hoisted in their places.

Such a battle could not be fought without sustaining a great loss of men. I have not only to lament in common with the British Navy, and the British Nation, in the fall of the Commander in Chief, the loss of a Hero, whose name will be immortal, and his memory ever dear to his country; but my heart is rent with the most poignant grief for the death of a friend, to whom, by many years intimacy, and a perfect knowledge of the virtues of his mind, which inspired ideas superior to the common race of men, I was bound by the strongest ties of affection; a grief to which even the glorious occasion in which he fell, does not bring the consolation which perhaps it ought; his Lordship received a musket ball in his left breast, about the middle of the action, and sent an officer to me immediately with his last farewell; and soon after expired.

I have also to lament the loss of those excellent officers, Captains Duff, of the Mars, and Cooke, of the Bellerophon; I have yet heard of no others.

I fear the numbers that have fallen will be found very great, when the returns come to me; but it having blown a gale of wind ever since the action, I have not yet had it in my power to collect any reports from the ships.

The Royal Sovereign having lost her masts, except the tottering foremast, I called the Euryalus to me, which the action continued, which ship lying within hail, made my signals, a service Captain Blackwood performed with great attention; after the action, I shifted my flag to her, that I might more easily communicate my orders to, and collect the ships, and towed the Royal Sovereign out to seaward. The whole fleet were now in a very perilous situation, many dismasted, all shattered, in thirteen fathom water, off the Shoals of Trafalgar, and when I made the signal to prepare to anchor, few of the ships had an anchor to let go, their cables being shot; but the same good Providence which aided us through such a day, preserved us in the night, by the wind shifting a few points, and drifting the ships off the land.

Having thus detailed the proceedings of the fleet on this occasion, I beg to congratulate their Lordships on a victory, which, I hope will add a ray to the glory of his Majesty's Crown, and be attended with public benefit to our country.

I am, &c.


Прочитайте, что пишет британец. Удар двумя колоннами оказался неожиданностью прежде всего для испанцев!

Вот так. Не больше, не меньше.
 Если же прибавить, что первым поворот ВСЕ ВДРУГ начал Гравина, то все становится на свои места. Испанцы в очередной раз подвели французов, у Гравины не выдержали нервы, и он решил если что сбежать в Кадис, что и позже сделал. Более того - после поворота бакштаг эскадра Гравины была под углом к колонне Колингвуда, и если бы положение таким и оставалось - британец попал бы в два огня, причем один из этих огней - продольный. Гравина делает просто - ОН СПРЯМЛЯЕТ ЛИНИЮ БЕЗ ПРИКАЗА НА ТО ВИЛЬНЕВА, и почти весь бой остается не у дел.
Так происходят  избиения младенцев
Я не вижу в Трафальгаре испанской гордости, это все равно что нам гордиться Небогатовым.

Tags: Ройал Неви, испанской флот, французский флот
Subscribe

  • Про Русский флот-2

    Ну а теперь пробежимся по 19-20 веку на предмет - а можно ли чем-то гордиться. Итак, 1806-1807 годы - экспедиция Сенявина. Блокада Турции со стороны…

  • Про Русский флот

    Тут задали вопрос, который очень часто задают со времен ВИФа любители сухопутных войск. Звучит он так: "А чем может похвастаться российский и…

  • Об очередной пробирке Пауэрса

    11 июля Гоуэр достиг Тильзита, где были расположены двор и русский император, и тот ему дрожащим от напряжения голосом зачел «совершенно…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 24 comments

  • Про Русский флот-2

    Ну а теперь пробежимся по 19-20 веку на предмет - а можно ли чем-то гордиться. Итак, 1806-1807 годы - экспедиция Сенявина. Блокада Турции со стороны…

  • Про Русский флот

    Тут задали вопрос, который очень часто задают со времен ВИФа любители сухопутных войск. Звучит он так: "А чем может похвастаться российский и…

  • Об очередной пробирке Пауэрса

    11 июля Гоуэр достиг Тильзита, где были расположены двор и русский император, и тот ему дрожащим от напряжения голосом зачел «совершенно…